Track Sources and Evidence
Short summary: When information comes from somewhere, tracking the source helps you check it, credit it, and find it again.
Big ideaβ
A source is where information came from. Evidence is information that supports a claim. Claims, sources, and evidence should stay connected β if you lose the source, it is much harder to check anything later.
Why it mattersβ
Source tracking helps with media, civic, legal, health, environmental, and school research. Not every source is equally useful for every question β and knowing where a fact came from is what lets you decide how much to trust it. Private or personal information needs extra care.
Kid-friendly explanationβ
A source tracker leaves breadcrumbs back to where information came from. Without the breadcrumbs, you may remember the fact but never find the path again β and then you cannot check it, share it, or defend it.
Tool: Claim / Source / Evidence / Questionβ
- Claim: ___
- Source: ___
- Evidence: ___
- What this source helps answer: ___
- Question I still have: ___
- Can I find it again? ___
Activity: Keep the Claim Connectedβ
Read or copy the supplied fictional cards. Match each claim to a source and evidence card, then add an open question. All cards are below; no searching or personal information is needed.
Claim cardsβ
| ID | Claim |
|---|---|
| C1 | Six kit checkouts were recorded on Tuesday. |
| C2 | The north shelf was scheduled to close Tuesday, 10 a.m.βnoon. |
| C3 | Using the kit makes everyone better at science. |
Source cardsβ
| ID | Source and contents |
|---|---|
| S1 | Fictional kit checkout log, Tuesday October 6: entries T1, T2, T3, T4, T5, T6. Each entry records one checkout; no borrower names or test results are included. |
| S2 | Fictional maintenance notice, issued October 5: "North shelf closed Tuesday October 6, 10 a.m.βnoon, for repair. Other shelves follow the usual schedule." |
| S3 | Fictional club blog, October 7: "Tuesday had six kit checkouts, according to log S1." No separate count was made. |
Evidence cardsβ
| ID | Evidence or evidence gap |
|---|---|
| E1 | Counting the six entries in S1 gives six recorded checkouts. |
| E2 | S2 states the shelf, date, and two-hour scheduled closure. |
| E3 | Someone remembers hearing C3, but the source, comparison, and measurements are missing. |
Facilitator answer notes: C1 β S1 β E1; ask whether all checkouts were recorded. Six checkouts does not necessarily mean six different people. S3 repeats S1 and is not an independent count; it can help locate S1. C2 β S2 β E2; ask whether a later notice changed the plan. A schedule does not prove the repair happened or that the whole building closed. C3 has no supplied supporting source; E3 is a gap, not support. Ask who made the claim and how "better" was measured. Label it unverified; losing a source does not prove a claim false. Accept other open questions that identify a real limit.
Discussion questionsβ
- Why does source tracking matter?
- What happens when a claim gets separated from its source?
- How can a source help one question but not another?
- What information should stay private?
Try it this weekβ
When you write down one fact, also write where it came from.
Adult noteβ
Source tracking is not just citation compliance β it protects thinking. Keep privacy and age-appropriate source choices in mind.