Skip to main content

Track Sources and Evidence

Short summary: When information comes from somewhere, tracking the source helps you check it, credit it, and find it again.

Big idea​

A source is where information came from. Evidence is information that supports a claim. Claims, sources, and evidence should stay connected β€” if you lose the source, it is much harder to check anything later.

Why it matters​

Source tracking helps with media, civic, legal, health, environmental, and school research. Not every source is equally useful for every question β€” and knowing where a fact came from is what lets you decide how much to trust it. Private or personal information needs extra care.

Kid-friendly explanation​

A source tracker leaves breadcrumbs back to where information came from. Without the breadcrumbs, you may remember the fact but never find the path again β€” and then you cannot check it, share it, or defend it.

Tool: Claim / Source / Evidence / Question​

  • Claim: ___
  • Source: ___
  • Evidence: ___
  • What this source helps answer: ___
  • Question I still have: ___
  • Can I find it again? ___

Activity: Keep the Claim Connected​

Read or copy the supplied fictional cards. Match each claim to a source and evidence card, then add an open question. All cards are below; no searching or personal information is needed.

Claim cards​

IDClaim
C1Six kit checkouts were recorded on Tuesday.
C2The north shelf was scheduled to close Tuesday, 10 a.m.–noon.
C3Using the kit makes everyone better at science.

Source cards​

IDSource and contents
S1Fictional kit checkout log, Tuesday October 6: entries T1, T2, T3, T4, T5, T6. Each entry records one checkout; no borrower names or test results are included.
S2Fictional maintenance notice, issued October 5: "North shelf closed Tuesday October 6, 10 a.m.–noon, for repair. Other shelves follow the usual schedule."
S3Fictional club blog, October 7: "Tuesday had six kit checkouts, according to log S1." No separate count was made.

Evidence cards​

IDEvidence or evidence gap
E1Counting the six entries in S1 gives six recorded checkouts.
E2S2 states the shelf, date, and two-hour scheduled closure.
E3Someone remembers hearing C3, but the source, comparison, and measurements are missing.

Facilitator answer notes: C1 β†’ S1 β†’ E1; ask whether all checkouts were recorded. Six checkouts does not necessarily mean six different people. S3 repeats S1 and is not an independent count; it can help locate S1. C2 β†’ S2 β†’ E2; ask whether a later notice changed the plan. A schedule does not prove the repair happened or that the whole building closed. C3 has no supplied supporting source; E3 is a gap, not support. Ask who made the claim and how "better" was measured. Label it unverified; losing a source does not prove a claim false. Accept other open questions that identify a real limit.

Discussion questions​

  • Why does source tracking matter?
  • What happens when a claim gets separated from its source?
  • How can a source help one question but not another?
  • What information should stay private?

Try it this week​

When you write down one fact, also write where it came from.

Adult note​

Source tracking is not just citation compliance β€” it protects thinking. Keep privacy and age-appropriate source choices in mind.